An appraisal is an opinion of market value prepared for the buyer or lender. If the appraised value comes in below the contract price, the problem is not simply that an appraiser 'disagreed' with the deal. The lender may base financing on the lower value, which can change the amount of cash the buyer needs to close.
First, measure the actual gap
A $5,000 shortfall on a $700,000 purchase is a different problem from a $50,000 shortfall. Buyers should ask the lender to show exactly how the appraisal changes loan-to-value, required cash, mortgage insurance or other terms. Sellers should compare the gap with current comparable sales and the risk of returning to market.
Colorado's conventional appraisal provision creates choices
Under the Colorado Real Estate Commission's 2026 residential contract, a conventional or other buyer who receives a value below the purchase price may have the right, subject to the contract and deadlines, to terminate or deliver an appraisal objection supported by the appraisal or lender verification. If the parties do not reach a written resolution by the Appraisal Resolution Deadline, the contract can terminate unless the buyer timely withdraws the objection.
Resolution can take several forms
The seller can reduce the price, the buyer can bring additional cash, the parties can split the difference, or the buyer can proceed under terms the lender permits. In some transactions an appraisal reconsideration may be appropriate if there are factual errors or relevant comparable sales were missed, but it should be based on evidence rather than frustration with the result.
FHA and VA financing have additional protections
The Colorado contract contains separate FHA and VA appraisal provisions. Those clauses can protect buyers from being obligated to complete a purchase above the applicable appraised or reasonable value, while still allowing the buyer to choose to proceed. Loan-specific rules need to be reviewed with the lender and the actual contract rather than applying conventional-loan assumptions to every deal.
A low appraisal is ultimately a negotiation around evidence, cash and risk. The strongest response is to understand the contract deadlines, confirm the lender's numbers, review the comparable sales and decide whether preserving the transaction still makes economic sense for both sides.
Source: Colorado Real Estate Commission 2026 Residential Contract to Buy and Sell Real Estate. This is general real-estate information, not legal or lending advice.
Related resources
Should Denver Buyers Wait for Home Prices To Fall?
How to Plan a Denver Metro Home Purchase Beyond the List Price